secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

Westfield Insurance vs. Selective Insurance Renters Insurance

Compare Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance to make an informed decision on the best coverage for your rented property and belongings.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
AllstateState FarmPrudentialMetLifeEthosAetna
Daniel S. Young

Insurance Content Managing Editor

Daniel S. Young began his professional career as chief editor of The Chanticleer, a Jacksonville State University newspaper. He also contributed to The Anniston Star, a local newspaper in Alabama. Daniel holds a BA in Communication and is pursuing an MA in Journalism & Media Studies at the University of Alabama. With a strong desire to help others protect their investments, Daniel has writt...

Written by
Daniel S. Young
Dani Best

Licensed Insurance Producer

Dani Best has been a licensed insurance producer for nearly 10 years. Dani began her insurance career in a sales role with State Farm in 2014. During her time in sales, she graduated with her Bachelors in Psychology from Capella University and is currently earning her Masters in Marriage and Family Therapy. Since 2014, Dani has held and maintains licenses in Life, Disability, Property, and Casualt...

Reviewed by
Dani Best

Updated January 2025

In the realm of securing your rented property and belongings, the choice between insurance providers becomes crucial. As you navigate the landscape of company names, specifically Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance, factors such as coverage rates, options, discounts, and reviews come to the forefront. Our in-depth analysis, exploring everything from coverage levels to the impact of credit scores and driving records, unveils the insights guiding you to the most advantageous rates tailored for different customer profiles. Whether it’s Westfield’s extensive coverage options or Selective’s focus on competitive rates, this comprehensive overview serves as a compass, allowing you to make an informed decision aligned with your unique requirements.

Westfield Insurance

Pros:

  • Long-Standing Reputation: With over 170 years of experience, Westfield Insurance has a robust and reliable history in providing insurance solutions.
  • Community Involvement: Westfield actively supports charitable organizations through its foundation, making a positive impact on the communities it serves.
  • Comprehensive Coverage: Westfield offers a range of coverage options, including personal property, liability protection, loss of use, and optional coverage for valuable items.
  • Customer Service: Known for exceptional customer service, Westfield Insurance has a dedicated team to assist policyholders, streamlined claims processes, and educational resources.

Cons:

  • Limited Geographic Presence: Westfield Insurance may have a more localized presence, potentially limiting availability in certain regions.
  • Possibly Higher Premiums: While providing comprehensive coverage, Westfield’s premium rates may be comparatively higher, impacting affordability for some renters.

Free Rental Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

Selective Insurance

Pros:

  • Nearly a Century of Operation: With a history dating back to 1926, Selective Insurance brings decades of experience and a reputation for reliability.
  • Competitive Rates: Selective Insurance focuses on offering competitive rates, making it an attractive option for budget-conscious renters.
  • Flexible Coverage Options: Selective Insurance provides comprehensive coverage for personal property, liability, and additional living expenses, with options for high-value items.
  • Exceptional Customer Service: Known for efficient and transparent claims processes, Selective Insurance values customer feedback and offers various communication channels.

Cons:

  • Possibly Less Community Involvement: Compared to Westfield, Selective Insurance’s community involvement may be less emphasized.
  • Limited Information on Optional Coverages: The extent of information on optional coverages or endorsements may not be as detailed, requiring further inquiry during the quote process.

Best Overall: Westfield Insurance

After a thorough examination of the features, coverage options, and overall offerings from Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance, Westfield emerges as the preferred choice for renters seeking comprehensive coverage and exceptional service. Why Westfield Insurance Stands Out:

Long-Standing Reputation: Westfield’s 170 years of experience in the insurance industry showcases a deep understanding of customer needs and a commitment to reliability.

Community Involvement: The active support of charitable organizations through the Westfield Insurance Foundation demonstrates a dedication to making a positive impact on the communities they serve.

Comprehensive Coverage: Westfield Insurance not only provides essential coverage for personal property, liability protection, and additional living expenses but also offers optional coverage for valuable items, allowing renters to tailor their policies to their unique needs.

Customer Service Excellence: With a streamlined claims process, a user-friendly online portal, and a team of knowledgeable professionals, Westfield Insurance ensures a hassle-free experience for policyholders. The commitment to education and customer support further solidifies its position as a customer-centric insurer.

While both companies offer competitive options, Westfield Insurance’s long-standing history, community engagement, and comprehensive coverage make it the best overall choice for renters looking for peace of mind and financial protection.

Understanding Renters Insurance

Before delving into the specifics of Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance, let’s first establish a foundation by exploring the basics of renters insurance. Renters insurance is designed to protect your personal property in the event of theft, damage, or loss. It also covers liability protection, protecting you if someone is injured on your rented property.

The Basics of Renters Insurance

Renters insurance typically consists of two main components: personal property coverage and liability coverage. Personal property coverage safeguards your belongings, including furniture, appliances, electronics, and even clothing. This means that if your apartment were to experience a fire or a break-in, your insurance policy would help cover the cost of replacing these items.

On the other hand, liability coverage offers financial protection if someone sues you for bodily injury or property damage that occurs within your rented home. For example, if a guest were to slip and fall in your apartment and decide to take legal action, your renters insurance would help cover the legal fees and any settlement or judgment costs.

It’s important to note that while the landlord’s insurance policy covers the structure of the building, it doesn’t extend coverage to your personal belongings. This is where renters insurance becomes crucial, providing the peace of mind you need.

Why Renters Insurance is Essential

Unexpected accidents can happen at any time, and without renters insurance, you’ll be left to bear the financial burden alone. Whether it’s a burst pipe damaging your furniture or a visitor getting injured on your property, the cost of replacement, repairs, or legal fees can be significant. Renters insurance acts as a safety net, ensuring that you are protected from these potential financial hardships.

Furthermore, renters insurance not only protects your personal belongings and provides liability coverage, but it also offers additional benefits. Some policies may include coverage for temporary living expenses if your rented property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss. This means that if your apartment were to suffer severe damage from a fire or a natural disaster, your insurance would help cover the cost of finding alternative accommodation while repairs are being made.

Additionally, renters insurance may also provide coverage for theft or damage to your belongings outside of your rented property. This means that if your laptop is stolen while you’re traveling or your bicycle is damaged while locked up outside a coffee shop, your insurance policy may help cover the cost of replacing these items.

Another benefit of renters insurance is that it often includes personal liability coverage, which extends beyond your rented property. This means that if you accidentally injure someone or damage their property while you’re away from home, your insurance policy may help cover the associated costs. For example, if you accidentally break a valuable item at a friend’s house or if your child damages school property, your renters insurance would provide financial protection.

In conclusion, renters insurance is an essential investment for anyone living in a rented property. It not only protects your personal belongings from theft, damage, or loss but also provides liability coverage in case of accidents or injuries. With the various benefits and coverage options available, renters insurance offers peace of mind and financial protection against unexpected events.

Free Rental Insurance Comparison

Compare Quotes From Top Companies and Save

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate

An Overview of Westfield Insurance

Now let’s shift our focus to Westfield Insurance, one of the leading providers of renters insurance. Understanding their history and background is essential in determining their credibility and reliability.

History and Background of Westfield Insurance

Westfield Insurance has been serving customers for over 170 years. Established in 1848, they have a long-standing reputation for providing comprehensive insurance solutions. Their journey began in the small town of Westfield Center, Ohio, where a group of farmers came together to protect their properties and livelihoods from potential risks.

Over the years, Westfield Insurance grew steadily, expanding its operations and offerings to meet the evolving needs of its customers. Today, they are a multi-line insurance company, providing coverage not only for renters but also for homeowners, businesses, and farms.

What sets Westfield Insurance apart is their commitment to community involvement. They actively support various charitable organizations and initiatives, aiming to make a positive impact on the communities they serve. Through their Westfield Insurance Foundation, they provide grants and donations to support education, health and human services, and disaster recovery efforts.

Westfield Renters Insurance: Coverage and Benefits

When it comes to renters insurance coverage, Westfield Insurance offers a range of options to fit varying needs. Their policies typically cover personal property, liability protection, loss of use, and additional living expenses in case you need temporary housing due to a covered event.

But Westfield Insurance goes beyond the basics. They understand that every renter has unique possessions and circumstances, which is why they provide optional coverage for valuable items such as jewelry, fine arts, and electronics. This extra layer of protection ensures that your most prized possessions are safeguarded against unexpected events.

Moreover, Westfield Insurance offers additional benefits to enhance the overall customer experience. Their online portal allows policyholders to easily manage their policies, make payments, and file claims. The company also provides educational resources and tools to help renters understand their coverage options and make informed decisions.

When it comes to customer service, Westfield Insurance is second to none. Their team of dedicated professionals is always ready to assist policyholders with any questions or concerns. Whether you need guidance in selecting the right coverage or require support during the claims process, their knowledgeable staff is there to provide personalized assistance.

Furthermore, Westfield Insurance’s claims process is streamlined and efficient, ensuring a hassle-free experience for policyholders. They understand the importance of prompt resolution and strive to settle claims quickly and fairly. With their commitment to customer satisfaction, you can trust that Westfield Insurance will be there for you when you need them the most.

An Overview of Selective Insurance

Let’s now turn our attention to Selective Insurance, another reputable provider of renters insurance. Understanding their background and offerings will establish a comprehensive comparison between the two providers.

History and Background of Selective Insurance

Selective Insurance has been in operation for nearly a century since its establishment in 1926. The company was founded by a group of forward-thinking individuals who recognized the need for reliable insurance coverage for renters. Over the years, Selective Insurance has grown and adapted to meet the changing needs of its customers, while staying true to its core values of integrity and exceptional service.

With a rich history and a focus on personalized coverage, Selective Insurance has become synonymous with reliability and outstanding customer service. Their commitment to understanding the unique needs of renters sets them apart from other insurance providers.

Throughout its long history, Selective Insurance has weathered various economic challenges and industry shifts. Their ability to adapt and innovate has allowed them to remain a trusted name in the insurance industry, providing peace of mind to countless renters across the country.

Selective Renters Insurance: Coverage and Benefits

Selective Insurance offers comprehensive coverage for renters, including personal property protection, liability coverage, and additional living expenses. Their policies can be tailored to fit the specific requirements of individual renters, ensuring maximum protection.

When it comes to personal property protection, Selective Insurance understands that renters have diverse needs. Their policies cover a wide range of items, from furniture and electronics to clothing and jewelry. With Selective Insurance, renters can have the confidence that their belongings are protected in the event of theft, fire, or other covered perils.

In addition to personal property protection, Selective Insurance provides liability coverage. This coverage protects renters in case someone is injured on their rented property and holds them responsible for medical expenses or legal fees. Selective Insurance understands the importance of having this safeguard in place, giving renters peace of mind.

Furthermore, Selective Insurance offers additional living expenses coverage. In the unfortunate event that a rented property becomes uninhabitable due to a covered loss, Selective Insurance will help cover the costs of temporary accommodations, meals, and other necessary expenses. This ensures that renters are not left stranded during a difficult time.

But Selective Insurance doesn’t stop there. They also provide optional coverage for high-value items, ensuring that even your most precious possessions are safeguarded. Whether it’s an expensive piece of artwork, a valuable collection, or a cherished family heirloom, Selective Insurance offers the flexibility to add extra protection for these items.

Exceptional Customer Service

When it comes to customer service, Selective Insurance excels. Their claims process is efficient and transparent, providing policyholders with the assistance they need during challenging times. Selective Insurance understands that filing a claim can be a stressful experience, so they strive to make it as seamless as possible.

From the moment a claim is initiated, Selective Insurance’s dedicated team of claims professionals is there to guide renters through the process. They provide clear communication, regular updates, and personalized support, ensuring that renters feel heard and supported every step of the way.

Moreover, Selective Insurance values feedback and continuously seeks ways to improve their customer service. They actively listen to their policyholders’ experiences and use that feedback to enhance their processes and offerings. With a strong focus on customer satisfaction, Selective Insurance strives to exceed expectations.

Additionally, Selective Insurance understands the importance of accessibility and convenience. They offer various channels for policyholders to reach out, including phone, email, and online chat. This ensures that renters can easily connect with Selective Insurance and have their questions answered promptly.

In conclusion, Selective Insurance has a long-standing reputation for providing reliable renters insurance coverage. Their rich history, comprehensive policies, and exceptional customer service make them a top choice for renters seeking peace of mind. Whether it’s protecting personal belongings, covering liability, or providing additional living expenses, Selective Insurance goes above and beyond to meet the unique needs of renters.

Comparing Westfield and Selective Renters Insurance

Now that we’ve explored the background and offerings of Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance, it’s time to compare the key factors that can aid in making a well-informed decision.

Coverage Comparison

Both Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance offer comprehensive coverage for renters. Their policies typically include personal property protection, liability coverage, and additional living expenses. This means that in the event of a covered loss, such as a fire or theft, your belongings will be protected, and you’ll have financial assistance for temporary living arrangements. However, it’s crucial to carefully review the specifics of each policy to ensure they align with your individual needs and preferences.

For example, Westfield Insurance might offer a higher coverage limit for personal property, while Selective Insurance might have a lower deductible for liability coverage. It’s important to consider factors such as the value of your belongings and the level of risk you’re comfortable with when selecting a policy.

Additionally, both providers offer optional coverage for valuable items, allowing you to customize your policy further. This can be particularly beneficial if you own expensive jewelry, electronics, or other high-value items that may not be fully covered under a standard policy.

Price Comparison

When comparing the cost of renters insurance between Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance, it’s essential to obtain personalized quotes from both providers. The price may vary based on factors such as your location, the value of your belongings, and the coverage limits you select.

It’s worth noting that while price is an important consideration, it shouldn’t be the sole determining factor in your decision. It’s crucial to strike a balance between affordability and the level of coverage and service you’ll receive. By obtaining quotes, you can make an accurate price comparison and choose the policy that offers the best value for your money.

Customer Satisfaction and Reviews Comparison

Customer satisfaction plays a pivotal role in choosing an insurance provider. Both Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance have a strong reputation for excellent customer service.

When considering customer satisfaction, it’s beneficial to read reviews from current and past policyholders to gauge their experiences. Consider factors such as ease of filing claims, responsiveness, and overall customer satisfaction. This will give you a better understanding of how each provider handles customer interactions and resolves issues.

It’s also worth noting that customer satisfaction can vary based on individual experiences. While one person may have had a positive experience with a particular provider, another may have encountered challenges. Therefore, it’s important to consider multiple reviews to get a well-rounded perspective.

In conclusion, when deciding between Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance for your renters insurance needs, it’s essential to consider their coverage options, prices, and customer satisfaction ratings. Both providers have a long-standing history of reliability and offer comprehensive coverage for renters. By conducting thorough research, obtaining personalized quotes, and reading customer reviews, you can make an informed decision and secure the protection you need for your rented home and personal belongings.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance for renters insurance?

Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance are both insurance companies that offer renters insurance. However, there are some differences between the two. Westfield Insurance is known for its comprehensive coverage options and personalized customer service. On the other hand, Selective Insurance focuses on providing competitive rates and flexible policy options. It is essential to compare their coverage limits, deductibles, and additional benefits to determine which insurance company suits your needs best.

What factors should I consider when choosing between Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance for renters insurance?

When choosing between Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance for renters insurance, it is important to consider several factors. These include the coverage limits offered, deductible options, additional benefits or endorsements available, customer service reputation, and premium rates. Assessing these factors will help you determine which insurance company provides the most suitable coverage for your specific needs and budget.

Can I get a quote for renters insurance from both Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance?

Yes, you can request a quote for renters insurance from both Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance. It is recommended to obtain quotes from multiple insurance companies to compare coverage options and rates. This will help you make an informed decision and choose the insurance company that offers the best value for your renters insurance needs.

Are there any discounts available for renters insurance with Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance?

Both Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance may offer various discounts for renters insurance. These discounts can vary based on factors such as having multiple policies with the same company, installing security systems or smoke detectors in your rental property, being claims-free, or having a good credit score. It is advisable to inquire about available discounts when obtaining quotes from these insurance companies to potentially lower your premium.

What are some additional coverages or endorsements that Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance offer for renters insurance?

Westfield Insurance and Selective Insurance may offer additional coverages or endorsements for renters insurance to enhance your policy’s protection. These can include coverage for valuable personal property, identity theft protection, water backup or sump overflow, earthquake coverage, and more. It is crucial to review the available endorsements and assess if any of them align with your specific needs to ensure comprehensive coverage.

Get a FREE Quote in Minutes

Insurance rates change constantly — we help you stay ahead by making it easy to compare top options and save.

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate
Liberty MutualAnthemAetnaMetLife

Free Insurance Comparison

Compare quotes from the top insurance companies and save!

secured lock Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

By clicking, you agree to our Terms of Use

Nationwide State Farm Allstate