North Star Mutual Insurance Review & Ratings (2025)

North Star insurance provides a variety of basic coverage types with many add-on coverages to customize your policy. The combination of personal and business insurance policies make it easy for business owners to get all of their coverage in one place. 

North Star also has discounts to allow its policyholders to save. However, many other insurance companies have more discounts to save with. With that being said, North Star may have cheaper rates to begin with, so discounts with other companies may not make sense. North Star may offer particularly low rates for young drivers, drivers with bad credit, or drivers with an at-fault accident on their driving record.

The most important thing you can do to ensure you’re getting the best insurance is to compare coverage and rates from multiple companies. If you can’t find affordable North Star Mutual insurance, enter your ZIP code into our free quote comparison tool below to compare rates from multiple companies in your area.

What You Should Know About North Star Mutual Insurance Company

Welcome to our comprehensive guide on North Star Mutual Insurance. In this article, we will delve into the details of North Star Mutual Insurance, including its coverage options, industry ratings, customer satisfaction, and more.

Whether you’re looking for home, auto, or farm insurance, we’ve got you covered. To ensure you get the best rates and coverage, we encourage you to enter your zip code and compare quotes from top insurance providers in your area. Don’t miss out on the opportunity to find reliable and affordable insurance that meets your specific needs.

North Star Mutual Insurance Company Insurance Coverage Options

North Star Mutual sells farm insurance, auto insurance, home insurance, business insurance, and umbrella insurance.

North Star Mutual farm insurance provides coverage that protects your farm, whether it functions as a home, business, or both. The policy will cover dwellings and farm structures, personal property linked to the home or farm, livestock, farm liability, and umbrella liability.

Other coverages that can be added to your farm insurance include sewer, drain, and sump system coverage, refrigerated food products coverage, farm operation records coverage, peak season coverage, livestock coverage, farm pollution/clean-up coverage, and many more. Discounts include new home discounts, security device discounts, multi-policy discounts, and higher deductible discounts.

North Star Mutual car insurance is available for personal and commercial needs. A personal policy will cover cars and other passenger vehicles, antique and classic cars, motor homes, trailers, motorcycles, and more. Basic coverages include liability, medical payments, personal injury protection, collision, comprehensive, and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.

Other coverages for a personal policy include rental reimbursement, roadside assistance, customization coverage, and glass coverage. Other coverages for a commercial auto insurance policy include non-owners auto coverage, miscellaneous coverage, and more. Discounts include anti-theft device discounts, passive restraint discounts, defensive driver discounts, and multi-policy discounts.

North Star Mutual home insurance will cover structures and property for homeowners and renters. Add-on coverages include sewer, drain, and sump system coverage, identity fraud expense coverage, expanded replacement coverage, watercraft liability, and more. Discounts include mature owner discounts, new home discounts, security device discounts, multi-policy discounts, and more.

North Star Mutual business insurance will cover commercial buildings, business personal property, commercial liability, umbrella liability, workers compensation, employment practices liability, and cyber liability. Its specialty business policies are for business owners, churches, contractors, and garages.

North Star Mutual umbrella insurance will expand the policy limits on your other insurance policies. North Star provides up to $5 million in liability, personal injury coverage, and optional uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.

North Star Mutual Insurance Company Insurance Rates Breakdown

Unfortunately, we were only able to find North Star Mutual insurance rates for its personal auto insurance policies. Let’s begin by looking at these rates below:

North Star Mutual Auto Insurance Rates by Age

While we couldn’t find rates specifically from North Star Mutual, we can show you some average rates to give you an idea of what you might pay for some of North Star’s insurance policies. For example, below are some average home insurance rates by coverage amount:

Average Home Insurance Rates by Coverage Amount

Finally, below are some sample rates for farm insurance:

Average Farm Insurance Rates by Coverage Type

Keep in mind that all of your insurance rates can vary based on many different factors, including your demographics, location, the value of the property you are insuring, and more.

North Star Mutual Insurance Company Discounts Available

Efficient North Star Mutual Insurance Services Claim Process: Filing Made Simple

Ease of Filing a Claim

Filing a claim with North Star Mutual Insurance is a straightforward process. Policyholders can report claims through various channels, including online, over the phone, or via their mobile apps. This flexibility ensures that you can choose the method that suits your preferences and convenience.

Average Claim Processing Time

North Star Mutual Insurance is known for its efficient claim processing. The company is committed to providing quick resolutions to claims, helping policyholders get the support they need promptly. Fast claim processing minimizes any disruptions caused by unexpected events.

Customer Feedback on Claim Resolutions and Payouts

Customer feedback on claim resolutions and payouts at North Star Mutual Insurance has been largely positive. Policyholders have praised the company’s commitment to fair and prompt claim settlements. North Star Mutual’s dedication to customer satisfaction shines through in its claims handling process.

Digital Advancements at North Star Mutual Insurance: Enhancing Your Coverage Experience

Mobile App Features and Functionality

North Star Mutual Insurance offers a feature-rich mobile app that simplifies insurance management. Policyholders can access their policies, file claims, view important documents, and make premium payments directly from the app. The user-friendly interface ensures a seamless experience.

Online Account Management Capabilities

Managing insurance policies online is effortless with North Star Mutual Insurance. The online account management portal provides access to policy details, billing information, and claims history. Policyholders can make updates, track claims, and review coverage at their convenience.

Digital Tools and Resources

North Star Mutual Insurance provides a range of digital tools and resources to empower policyholders in making informed insurance decisions. From educational materials to calculators, these resources offer valuable insights for effective insurance management. The company’s commitment to technology enhances the overall insurance experience.

How North Star Mutual Insurance Company Ranks Among Providers

When exploring insurance options, it’s crucial to consider the competitors alongside North Star Mutual Insurance. Here are some key competitors in the insurance industry:

• State Farm Insurance: State Farm is a giant in the insurance industry, offering a wide range of coverage options, including auto, home, life, and business insurance. Known for its extensive network of agents and a strong emphasis on customer service, State Farm competes with North Star Mutual by providing comprehensive policies and a range of discounts.
• Progressive Corporation: Progressive is recognized for its innovative approach to auto insurance, particularly its usage-based insurance programs like Snapshot. As a direct insurer, Progressive competes by leveraging technology to provide competitive rates and customizable policies, especially in the auto insurance sector.
• Farmers Insurance Group: Farmers Insurance is a major player in the insurance market, offering diverse coverage options, including home, auto, life, and business insurance. With a focus on personalized service, Farmers competes with North Star Mutual by catering to a broad spectrum of insurance needs.
• Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company: Nationwide operates as a mutual company, similar to North Star Mutual, and provides a range of insurance products, including auto, home, and business insurance. Nationwide’s extensive network and emphasis on member-centric policies position it as a competitor in the insurance landscape.

Each of these competitors brings its unique strengths and strategies to the table. State Farm’s widespread agent network, Progressive’s technological innovation, Farmers Insurance’s focus on personalized service, and Nationwide’s mutual structure all contribute to a dynamic and competitive insurance market.

When considering insurance providers, it’s essential to evaluate not only coverage options but also the overall customer experience and innovation each competitor brings to the industry.

In-Depth Analysis of North Star Mutual Insurance Services and Ratings

North Star Mutual Insurance Company has garnered attention for its comprehensive coverage options and reliable services. The North Star auto warranty is particularly praised for its extensive protection plans, ensuring vehicle owners are well-covered against unexpected repairs.

Additionally, the North Star payment system is user-friendly, providing flexible and convenient payment options for policyholders. Customers have noted that the North Star insurance company offers some of the cheapest homeowners insurance in Minnesota, making it a popular choice among budget-conscious homeowners.

Access to services is streamlined through the North Star agent login, which allows North Star agents to manage client accounts efficiently. Moreover, the North Star extended warranty enhances the appeal of their auto insurance products, offering extended coverage for older vehicles.

Customer service is a standout feature, as evidenced by the easy-to-navigate North Star claims process, backed by a responsive support team. Clients of North Star Community Credit Union also benefit from seamless integration with their insurance products, including North Star home insurance.

The company maintains a strong reputation, bolstered by positive North Star insurance advisors reviews and a robust network through the North Star insurance agency. For those needing assistance, the North Star insurance claims phone number and physical presence in North Star insurance Cottonwood MN ensure prompt service.

While there are occasional North Star Mutual complaints, the company offsets these with substantial North Star insurance services and North Star Mutual discounts. Additionally, North Star Mutual’s offerings in star car insurance and star home insurance further solidify their standing in the insurance market.

Unlocking Excellence: North Star Mutual Insurance Services and Reviews

Navigating Assurance: North Star Mutual Insurance in Review

What are North Star Mutual’s industry ratings?

North Star Mutual Insurance Company has an A+ rating from A.M. Best, which means that it has a superior ability to meet its financial obligations. Its long-term issuer credit rating is aa-, which means that it has a superior ability to repay its long-term debt.

North Star’s NAIC complaint index is 0.81. Compared to the national average of 1.00, North Star’s rating indicates that it gets fewer complaints than companies of a similar size. However, the few North Star Mutual insurance reviews that can be found online show that some customer service representatives and claims adjusters are very helpful.

North Star has a BBB rating of A+.

How do I contact North Star Mutual?

North Star Mutual is located at 269 Barstad Road S, PO Box 48, Cottonwood, MN 56229. The phone number is (800) 622-5230 or (507) 423-6262. The North Star Mutual fax number is (507) 423-6323.

General questions can be sent to info@northstarmutual.com. However, North Star Mutual Insurance Company bill pay questions can be sent to accounting@northstarmutual.com. In most cases, you can receive faster and more in-depth help from your insurance agent.